evolve-results.tsv

round	flaw	category	severity	old_total	new_total	verdict	reason
1	Role override g/d parsed anywhere in arguments, not just first position — causes false matches in target text	parsing	4	37	38	KEEP	New version edges ahead on depth and actionability with marginal net improvement
2	Intensity tokens hard/soft parsed anywhere in arguments — causes false matches in target text like "the hard drive design"	parsing	4	37	40	KEEP	New version names more competitors, adds liability angle, offers sharper actionable advice
3	Discriminator has no special handling for first-round invocations against raw unformed ideas — applies full 5-section attack prematurely	logic	3	34	37	KEEP	Reconnaissance Mode digs deeper per risk with nuanced reasoning and ends with sharp killer question
4	gan	#2 life-decision	soft Generator has no defined behavior — only D has Socratic Mode details, G soft is undefined	logic	3	-	-	REVERT	Old version produced more concrete and actionable output without the explicit soft G rules
5	gan	#3 architecture	Reconnaissance Mode has no interaction rules with intensity modes — soft demands questions while Recon demands risk list	logic	3	-	-	REVERT	Old version freely combined risks + questions producing richer output than strict questions-only rule